Who would have thought that the Vice Presidential debate would have been the most entertaining and civil of this election cycle.
I did not have high hopes for civility. Joe Biden threw the first firebomb of the debate on the second question asked. Worse still his firebomb was an out-of-context parrot point of a sound bite that made Old Joe look trite. Palin parried with the ease she failed to show when chatting with Katie Couric. Palin countered Biden’s assault with kindness. She then hijacked the Obama campaign’s “change” theme repeatedly using the word “new”.
I think this opening rhetorical artillery exchange shook Biden and he never recovered.
Palin then did something Biden can’t, namely play the Mom card. She spoke at a personal level that likely connected with average people despite sounding a bit canned. The topic in this round was how the sub-prime mortgage mess came about, and Palin exposed the foolishness of some home buyers who purchased houses and chose mortgages that were way beyond their means. Biden countered claiming that a lack of government regulation was the cause. This tiny tit for tat clearly demarked their political philosophies — the divide between individual responsibility and government paternalism.
The former won, or at least that is what a live focus group hosted by Fox News indicated. This group of equally divided Blues and Reds wielded devices they dialed to express their (dis)agreement with the speaker. When Palin spoke on personal and government responsibility, everyone in the room agreed with her in the 90% range.
That will be very dangerous to the Obama campaign.
The Democrat perspective showed through again as Biden lobbied for their “rob the rich” tax plan expressing nearly open anger (I may be reading too much into this moment of the debate — Biden always looks angry). Joe appeared nasty while Palin came across as sympatric to the condition of The People, poor and rich. Biden responded by diving headlong into a convoluted number-dump on health care costs. He lobbed scare tactic statistics like verbal hand grenades in a blunt attempt to frighten swing voters.
Anger, fear, and robbery. What a winning combo. Obama may be dialing Hillary’s cell phone to ask if it is too late to reconsider his choice in running mates.
One recurring observation: Biden is spooky. He has sudden facial expression changes, switching from a snarl to an overplayed smile, to a frown in less time than it takes Bill Clinton to unzip. He came off looking schizophrenic and manic, two qualities nobody wants in a man with his a finger on the ICBM launch button.
Palin spent time discussing solutions and political philosophy. Biden spent his time slinging mud. Palin was able to rattle off world leader names and articulate foreign policy talking points with ease, which is counter to the pre-game analysis by politicos. She surprised many people, especially Biden.
The big shock was that Palin distanced herself from the Bush administration, flatly stating that the Bushies made massive blunders. No nuance — Bush bumbled. Biden repeatedly tried to tie McCain to Bush but his attempts were ham-handed and fell flat. Joe delivered these lines in the same way that linebackers dance ballet. When Biden claimed the U.S. General in charge of the Afghanistan campaign said a “surge” would not work, Palin debunked and dunked Biden — and he was visibly shaken.
Palin’s only tactical error was closing the debate by saying that the main stream media would filter the debate results. This may well be true but even if the MSM is in the tank for Obama, it never helps to pick a fight with people who buy ink by the barrel and own satellite uplink ground stations.
I won’t claim that Palin won the debate, but she held her own and showed that she is more than ready to be a Vice President. Joe proved nothing. You do the scoring from there.