Email This Post
Freely Stupid
July 29th, 2010Everyone has the right to be stupid. Unfortunately some people abuse the privilege.
Take the two cases of Jennifer Keeton and Julea Ward, who independently have (il)logical or religious problems with homosexuals. Both are or were students in public universities (Augusta State and Eastern Michigan respectively) in graduate programs for counseling. Both women – who are attractive enough to convert Castro District regulars – had the poor judgment to publicly discuss what they thought.
Keeton believes homosexuality is a personal choice and lifestyle but not a “state of being.” The two are not mutually exclusive. Some homo sapiens are clearly hardwired from birth to prefer people with similar plumbing. Others have no particular preference, and choose through trial and Eros. Keeton sees only one of the two alternatives, which means she suffers from intellectual myopia.
Ward is worse in believing that homosexuality is morally wrong. One dictionary defines morality as “conformity to the rules of right conduct.” In an allegedly free society like America, “right conduct” is theoretical. The People have clearly said that as long as one’s behavior does not purposefully or negligently harm someone else, there is no “wrong” conduct (granted our laws often violate this principle, but that is why The People prefer physically violating their elected officials). Ward’s assessment is based on her own perception of “right conduct”, which she is free to inscribe on the inside of whatever woman’s thigh she wishes to lick.
Or not. It is allegedly a free country.
What makes their cases problematic is that they are being tossed out of college onto their perky little heterosexual keisters. In statements sounding Soviet, the administrators of Augusta State have asked that Keeton be indoctrinated. A District Judge upheld Ward’s prior dismissal for declining to guide gays and deliberate with dykes. Keeton was told she had to attend a “remediation program”, which is academic literary effluvium for “reeducation camp” and an attempt to force a fellow human to think what she doesn’t. With Ward, she was ousted for refusing to counsel people pertaining to matters that she personally opposed based on her religious beliefs.
Who is a girl going to abide by – her God or her government. Well, God does have seniority.
Several collisions between individual rights are at play here. People have the right to believe what they like, and no government has the right to force them to believe otherwise. Consumers have the right to spend their money as they see fit, including taxpayers forced to lob lucre into state colleges. People have the right of association, which includes the right from association, and thus cannot be compelled to counsel anyone they dislike for whatever inane reasons they may have for disliking them. Being taxpayers themselves, Keeton and Ward have equal access rights to public universities, and morality codices – be they the student’s or the public’s as reflected through government schools – cannot keep them from access. Equal access to taxpayer funded counseling services are also extended to taxpaying lumber dykes and butt pirates.
Solomon couldn’t solve this dispute.
Unsurprisingly the correct solution is the most difficult, untenable and unpolitical of them all. Eliminating government universities solves the whole mess rather nicely. Keeton and Ward could wonder off to whatever educational institutes of parochial paranoia they prefer, obtain degrees with their own capital, and in their subsequent careers commit whatever malpractice they prefer. Taxpayers would then be unburdened and could invest directly into the university, curriculum and state of (un)consciousness they conceive. Everyone can be made happy by cutting government out of the equation.
Which is why it won’t happen in my lifetime. Government, the original virus, tends to grow, mutate and infect until the host dies or some powerful antibody (a.k.a. revolution) occurs. Americans have failed to contain the pathogen called government, and thus we must suffer the disease until death or a butt full of armed antiseptics is administered.
A Mexican stand-off (ooops, sorry, an undocumented stand-off) remains. Freedom of thought must be preserved and thus all attempts by government to force conformity must be eradicated. Keeton and Ward cannot be dismissed from their equal access/opportunity educational path because they think wrong (and there are only three crimes in the word – the crime of being stupid, the crime of thinking wrong, and the crime of driving with your head up your rump). Government cannot keep these women from university programs on “thinking wrong” grounds, nor can Mao-like reeducation camps become a substitute for reasoned or unreasonable disagreement. Government caused this problem by getting into the higher education business, and more government is the worst possible solution.
Ostracization however is always effective.
Nobody can be compelled to associate. You cannot be forced to like someone else or say a civil word to them. Shame is an underused tool in modern society, and one that would be very applicable here. Living in San Francisco I have numerous friends and acquaintances who are members in good standing of the Church of the Carpet Chewer or the Sausage Factory Synagogue. Can’t say I find a dimes worth of difference between a diesel dyke and a truck drivin’ man, except that the dyke might have more chin stubble. Homos are people with preferences (and I even share some preferences with lesbians). It is impossible for anyone who has spent significant time around the other clans to see them as immoral, living a “lifestyle” instead of possessing pre-existing preferences, or unworthy of counseling. Doing so would be stupid.
Stupid people we mock. Shame them for willful ignorance. Deride their lack of insight, empathy and intelligence. So let Keeton and Ward keep their educational opportunity while we individually marginalize their very existence. Let’s assure that their social isolation is so profound they will need counseling themselves.
















