Email This Post
Less Filling
August 7th, 2009A recent review of AFTERLIFE said (and I paraphrase) “I wish the book was longer.”
AFTERLIFE is a novella, and thus condemned to abbreviated stature. It is novella length for one simple reason: that was all it took to tell the story well. I’m loathe mindlessly padding stories in order make it novel length and thus attractive to publishers, though not more attractive to readers.
Many writers succumb to their padded sells. My favorite writer, Robert Heinlein, only fell victim to this literary disease once or twice. When he did I always felt cheated. One Heinlein book, padded more thickly than a teenage girl’s bra, was little more than an opening chapter, a closing chapter, and 300 pages of backfill.
Fill not! It hurts your readers and eventually it hurts you … sometimes.
I had these thought ricocheting in my alleged mind while rapidly reading he early chapters of John Grisham’s THE LAST JUROR. I have never read Grisham before, not out of any distain aside from my glow-in-the-dark jealously for obscenely rich writers. It had never occurred to me to read Grisham simply his themes are ones to which I have no strong attachment. But a family member bought me a copy of JUROR for a present, and I grabbed it while heading off the bar one night.
The man makes fill taste good.
Perhaps my analysis is premature, having ingested only the first 100 pages (386 to go). The story is well constructed with little literary flotsam. Around page 80 he diverges into a detailed account of meeting a character, discussing the appearance of her house and garden, his gastronomic indifferences, her Southern cuisine and his newfound gluttony. Ten pages of prose that may add to the story later on, but which was mostly fill.
It is magnificent fill. It added texture, amplifying aspects of the town in which the book is set and the ‘outsider’ protagonist’s journey through it. Nine of those ten pages could have gone away and not affected your understanding of the plot, but they are not wasted because they are a well cooked accent, like a fine parfait after six courses.
There is fulfillment and there is landfill. If you need to pad a book, make the added prose descriptive and simultaneously wrapped around the characters (and think of towns, animals and other non-human elements as characters). Use it to deepen the relationship your reader has with those people and places that drive the story. These won’t be empty words that waste your audience’s time and patience.









